OpeItcLoc03/claude-skills
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

meta(tasks): close [meta-host-routing-review] — VERDICT PASS

Browse Source 
Skill-review checkpoint for meta-host-routing v0.3.0 (non-implementer).
Behavioral smoke-test 8/8 via clean-context subagents: 5/5 positive
trigger phrases (RU+EN) route to meta-host-routing, 3/3 negatives routed
away (using-projects-meta / delegate-task[Skip-clause] / using-tasks).
Zero false positives. Steps verified against live infra: yt-tools resolves
to dedicated host OpeItcLoc03/meta-yt-tools (projects-meta tracks it),
.common grep returns hits, excludesFile + ~/.config/git/ignore + auth.toml
present. Failure modes -> STOP+ask; What-NOT-to-do accurate. No blocking
findings on the skill.

Observation (not a skill defect): the review-task acceptance criterion
'resolves .common' is stale — skill v0.3.0 and reality route yt-tools to
the dedicated meta-yt-tools host; .common now holds only the done-archive.
Caveat: -install and -hermes-mapping baselines remain open (skill not in
~/.claude/skills nor hermes/mapping.yaml); this review covers content +
trigger discrimination only, not live-harness activation.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
vitya
2026-06-11 12:46:53 +03:00
parent 14f22033f3
commit 0e7e0c065a
1 changed files with 6 additions and 8 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

14
.tasks/STATUS.md
View File

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
# Task Board
_Updated: 2026-06-11 — task-format skill v0.1.0 created (TDD via writing-skills; RED 3-fail → GREEN 2-pass). Ранее: using-markitdown-cli-rewrite-review done (VERDICT PASS; SKILL.md без `mcp__markitdown__`, CLI-примеры совпадают с `markitdown 0.1.6 --help`, version 1.0.0→1.0.1 PATCH, dist консистентен; 1 informational finding — docker-контейнер респаунится из out-of-scope `~/.claude.json` MCP-регистрации → follow-up `using-markitdown-mcp-deregister` needs-human). Ранее: skill-using-system-snapshot-review done (VERDICT PASS 3/3; live tool-contract verify + 9-way fresh-context trigger test, 8 clean; 3 informational findings, none blocking — incl. missing deployment scaffold: skill not installed / not in hermes-mapping / no baseline tasks). Ранее: using-tasks-status-read-perf done (using-tasks 1.2.0→1.3.0; done-task archival rule fixes STATUS.md bloat; literal `tasks_get_status`-for-orientation swap NOT done — tool can't enumerate the board, documented). Ранее: session-break-using-tasks done (using-tasks 1.1.0→1.2.0; `session_break` marker — stop after close before claim-next). Ранее: delegate-task-review done (VERDICT PASS; smoke-test 6/6 fresh subagents, no blocking findings, 3 informational notes). Ранее: delegate-task-test-trigger done (pos 5/5, neg 2/3; FP на «создать задачу себе» → follow-up delegate-task-description-fp-fix, shipped v0.2.1). Ранее (2026-06-08): откат churn'а от агент-раннера (always-on dry-run): 5 тасок (using-yt-tools-rate-limit-guard, archive-roundtrip-test, skills-grouping-revisit, hermes-converter-ci, tdd-criteria-precommit-hook) спуриозно claimed/blocked из-за workspace-divergence бага раннера → возвращены в ⚪ ready. yt-tools re-scoped на plugin-репо `OpeItcLoc03/yt-tools` (исходный stub deprecated)._
_Updated: 2026-06-11 — meta-host-routing-review closed (VERDICT PASS; behavioral 8/8 via clean-context subagents — 5 pos→meta-host-routing, 3 neg routed away incl. known-Gitea Skip-clause; Steps verified vs live infra: yt-tools→OpeItcLoc03/meta-yt-tools dedicated host resolves, .common grep hits, excludesFile/auth.toml present; failure-modes→STOP+ask, What-NOT accurate; no blocking findings on skill v0.3.0. Observation: task acceptance «resolves .common» is stale — skill+reality route yt-tools to dedicated meta-yt-tools host. Caveat: -install + -hermes-mapping baselines remain ⚪ open — skill not in ~/.claude/skills nor hermes/mapping.yaml; review covers content+trigger-discrimination only, not live-harness activation). Ранее: task-format skill v0.1.0 created (TDD via writing-skills; RED 3-fail → GREEN 2-pass). Ранее: using-markitdown-cli-rewrite-review done (VERDICT PASS; SKILL.md без `mcp__markitdown__`, CLI-примеры совпадают с `markitdown 0.1.6 --help`, version 1.0.0→1.0.1 PATCH, dist консистентен; 1 informational finding — docker-контейнер респаунится из out-of-scope `~/.claude.json` MCP-регистрации → follow-up `using-markitdown-mcp-deregister` needs-human). Ранее: skill-using-system-snapshot-review done (VERDICT PASS 3/3; live tool-contract verify + 9-way fresh-context trigger test, 8 clean; 3 informational findings, none blocking — incl. missing deployment scaffold: skill not installed / not in hermes-mapping / no baseline tasks). Ранее: using-tasks-status-read-perf done (using-tasks 1.2.0→1.3.0; done-task archival rule fixes STATUS.md bloat; literal `tasks_get_status`-for-orientation swap NOT done — tool can't enumerate the board, documented). Ранее: session-break-using-tasks done (using-tasks 1.1.0→1.2.0; `session_break` marker — stop after close before claim-next). Ранее: delegate-task-review done (VERDICT PASS; smoke-test 6/6 fresh subagents, no blocking findings, 3 informational notes). Ранее: delegate-task-test-trigger done (pos 5/5, neg 2/3; FP на «создать задачу себе» → follow-up delegate-task-description-fp-fix, shipped v0.2.1). Ранее (2026-06-08): откат churn'а от агент-раннера (always-on dry-run): 5 тасок (using-yt-tools-rate-limit-guard, archive-roundtrip-test, skills-grouping-revisit, hermes-converter-ci, tdd-criteria-precommit-hook) спуриозно claimed/blocked из-за workspace-divergence бага раннера → возвращены в ⚪ ready. yt-tools re-scoped на plugin-репо `OpeItcLoc03/yt-tools` (исходный stub deprecated)._
<!--
Canonical layout. One block per task. Per-task deep context lives in
@@ -375,7 +375,7 @@ NB: эта таска сама уйдёт в следующий cleanup batch (2
---
## 🔴 [meta-host-routing-review] — Skill-review checkpoint для meta-host-routing (промоушен 2026-05-27).
## 🟢 [meta-host-routing-review] — Skill-review checkpoint для meta-host-routing (промоушен 2026-05-27).
**Источник дизайна:** `~/projects/.workshop/.archive/2026-05-10-meta-out-of-repo.md` (правило) + причина создания в `.workshop/.wiki/log.md` (2026-05-27).
**Импл-таски:** meta-host-routing-install, -hermes-mapping, -test-trigger.
@@ -395,14 +395,12 @@ Findings → follow-up tasks в claude-skills.
**Закрытие:** когда findings зафайлены ИЛИ «нет findings» в close-note. Семвер дальше — владелец claude-skills.
**Status:** active
**Where I stopped:** (not started)
**Next action:** Дождаться 🟢 у 3 baseline-тасок. Прогнать поведенческий smoke-test. Findings → follow-up tasks.
**Status:** done
**Where I stopped:** Ревью прогнано 2026-06-11 против текущего v0.3.0 (НЕ имплементер; baseline `-test-trigger` субсумирован этим smoke-тестом). **Вердикт: PASS, нет блокирующих findings.** (1) Behavioral smoke-test 8/8 чисто через clean-context субагентов (simulated registry: meta-host-routing + using-projects-meta/using-tasks/delegate-task/setup-tasks/project-bootstrap, без подсказки ожидаемого ответа): positives 5/5 → meta-host-routing (P1 not-in-cache, P2 github-remote, P3 RU «заведи таски в github-проект», P4 RU «промоутни yt-tools», P5 EN github-hosted); negatives 3/3 мимо (N1 «по всем проектам»→using-projects-meta, N2 «заведи таску в books» known-Gitea→delegate-task [явно сослался на Skip-клаузу], N3 «обнови статус … в текущем проекте»→using-tasks). Ноль false-positive. (2) Steps executable против ЖИВОЙ инфры: Step 2a yt-tools→`OpeItcLoc03/meta-yt-tools` резолвится (projects-meta трекает доску); Step 2b grep yt-tools в `.common` даёт хиты; excludesFile+`~/.config/git/ignore` паттерны+auth.toml на месте. (3) Failure modes все уводят в STOP+ask / детерминированный recovery, не в гадание. (4) What-NOT-to-do — все 4 пункта реальны и консистентны со Skip-клаузой. (5) Completeness vs design: тело верно операционализирует meta-out-of-repo; `meta-<project>` naming укоренён в archive option-(ii) + уточнён 2026-05-27. **Findings: нет (на сам скил).** Observation (не дефект скила): acceptance-критерий этой таски «резолвит `.common`» УСТАРЕЛ — скил v0.3.0 + реальность роутят yt-tools в dedicated host `OpeItcLoc03/meta-yt-tools` (`.common` держит только done-архив); скил СВЕЖЕЕ спеки, само-резолвится этим закрытием. **Caveat (deployment):** `-install` и `-hermes-mapping` baselines НЕ зелёные — скил не в `~/.claude/skills/` и не в `hermes/mapping.yaml`; ревью покрывает только content+trigger-discrimination (subagent-proxy registry), НЕ живую активацию в харнесе и не build-зелёность. Эти 2 остаются под своими ⚪ тасками; новых follow-up НЕ завожу.
**Next action:** (none — closed by review, нет блокирующих findings; семвер дальше — владелец claude-skills). `-test-trigger` фактически покрыт (8/8) — закрыть его может владелец отдельно.
**Branch:** n/a
**Owner:** DESKTOP-NSEF0UK:claude-opus:21356
**Claim token:** 8112f503-26e0-4d0c-a609-85efa9954d07
**Claim expires at:** 2026-06-11T09:55:05.889Z
<!-- created-by: OpeItcLoc03@DESKTOP-NSEF0UK / from: OpeItcLoc03/workshop / 2026-05-27T06:51:48.622Z -->
<!-- closed-by: DESKTOP-NSEF0UK:claude-opus:21356 / 2026-06-11 / VERDICT PASS; behavioral 8/8 (5 pos→mhr, 3 neg routed away), Steps verified vs live infra (meta-yt-tools host + .common grep), failure-modes→STOP, What-NOT accurate; no blocking findings; observation: task acceptance «.common» stale (skill v0.3.0 routes yt-tools→meta-yt-tools); caveat: install+hermes-mapping baselines still open -->
---