vitya
6c83a35d6d
Cross-machine workflows broke silently when the agent reasoned on a stale
MCP cache, or hit sha-based optimistic-lock 422s on shared-wiki writes
because another host had pushed minutes earlier. Codify the missing
pre-flight as Step 0:
1. Always probe mcp__projects-meta__meta_status first.
2. If cache_age_minutes > 10 OR errors_count > 0 → run
`node ~/.local/projects-meta-mcp/dist/sync.js` before any read.
3. For shared-wiki WRITES (knowledge_ingest, knowledge_promote) →
unconditional `git -C ~/projects/projects-wiki pull --ff-only`
(sha-lock will reject the commit otherwise; failure is opaque).
4. Tasks-mutations: sync via dist/sync.js is enough (no local clone
of target tasks repo).
5. Sync 401/403 → STOP, send user to ~/.config/projects-mcp/auth.toml
to rotate gitea_token. No silent retry.
10-minute cache window chosen as the read threshold — balances
multi-machine drift detection against unnecessary Gitea round-trips.
Common mistakes + Red flags expanded to call out the new failure modes.
README mirrors the rule for human readers. Wiki concept page
projects-meta-skills.md gets a "Freshness gate (v1.1.0)" subsection.
Closes [using-projects-meta-freshness-gate].
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
35 lines
4.6 KiB
Markdown
35 lines
4.6 KiB
Markdown
# using-projects-meta-freshness-gate
|
||
|
||
## Goal
|
||
Add an explicit Step 0 "Freshness gate" to `using-projects-meta` so the agent does not hit a stale MCP cache or a sha-based optimistic-lock conflict in cross-machine workflows. Pre-flight: always `meta_status`; if `cache_age` > 10 min or `errors_count` > 0, run `node ~/.local/projects-meta-mcp/dist/sync.js` for reads; for shared-wiki writes (`knowledge_ingest`, `knowledge_promote`) additionally `git -C ~/projects/projects-wiki pull --ff-only`. 401/403 from sync → token expired → send user to `~/.config/projects-mcp/auth.toml`. Tasks-mutations need only the sync (no local clone of target tasks repo). Bump skill 1.0.0 → 1.1.0 (additive, non-breaking).
|
||
|
||
## Key files
|
||
- `skills/using-projects-meta/SKILL.md` — add **Step 0 — Freshness gate** section before "Read (no confirmation needed)" and before "Mutate (always two-step)"; tweak Workflow ordering
|
||
- `skills/using-projects-meta/README.md` — mirror the rule in a new "Freshness gate" subsection of "Two operation classes"
|
||
- `.wiki/concepts/projects-meta-skills.md` — append a "Freshness gate (v1.1.0)" subsection
|
||
- `.wiki/log.md` — one entry
|
||
|
||
## Decisions log
|
||
- 2026-04-30: Threshold = 10 min cache age. Reason: balance between catching cross-machine pushes and not hitting Gitea on every casual `tasks_aggregate`. User-supplied number, codified.
|
||
- 2026-04-30: For shared-wiki writes, pull is **unconditional** (not gated by cache age). Reason: sha-based optimistic lock in `knowledge_ingest` will reject the commit otherwise with a 422, and the failure mode is opaque ("why did it fail?"). The pull is cheap (fast-forward is a no-op when already current).
|
||
- 2026-04-30: For tasks-mutations, sync via `dist/sync.js` is enough. Reason: there's no local clone of the target tasks repo — mutations go straight through Gitea API. The sync only refreshes the local view of all repos' STATUS.md so the agent reasons from current state when writing.
|
||
- 2026-04-30: 401/403 from sync → send user to rotate `gitea_token` in `~/.config/projects-mcp/auth.toml`. Reason: silently failing or pretending sync succeeded leaves the agent reasoning on stale data. Loud failure is the whole point of the check.
|
||
- 2026-04-30: Version bump 1.0.0 → 1.1.0 (additive behavior change — adds a pre-flight step, doesn't break existing usage). `using-context7` precedent: `version` in frontmatter, semver discipline.
|
||
|
||
## Open questions
|
||
- [ ] Should Step 0 apply to `meta_status` itself? Decision: no — that would be circular. `meta_status` is the freshness probe, not a read that depends on freshness.
|
||
|
||
## Completed steps
|
||
- [x] Open task in STATUS.md as 🔴 active
|
||
- [x] Add Step 0 — Freshness gate section to `using-projects-meta/SKILL.md` (between Workflow header and Read sub-section); add Step 0 reference to Read and Mutate sub-flows; extend Common mistakes (3 new rows: stale aggregate, skipped pull, sync 401/403); extend Red flags (2 new bullets)
|
||
- [x] Mirror rule in `using-projects-meta/README.md` as new "Step 0 — Freshness gate (v1.1.0, mandatory pre-flight)" section
|
||
- [x] Bump `version: 1.0.0` → `1.1.0` in SKILL.md frontmatter
|
||
- [x] First rebuild + reinstall — caused regression: full Step 0 inlined into description took it to ~1450 chars, exceeded harness limit, description silently dropped → listing showed `using-projects-meta: Using the projects-meta MCP server` (H1 fallback); fixed by trimming description to 924 chars with one-sentence pointer "v1.1.0 mandates a Step 0 freshness gate ... see SKILL body"
|
||
- [x] Saved feedback memory `skill_description_length_limit.md` so future me checks length after frontmatter edits
|
||
- [x] Wiki: appended "Freshness gate (v1.1.0)" subsection to `concepts/projects-meta-skills.md`; one entry in `log.md`
|
||
- [x] Closed in STATUS.md (🟢 done); next: commit + push + MCP round-trip close
|
||
|
||
## Notes
|
||
- User-supplied draft text for the skill (verbatim): _"Step 0 — Freshness gate. Always call mcp__projects-meta__meta_status first. If cache_age_minutes > 10 or errors.length > 0, run node ~/.local/projects-meta-mcp/dist/sync.js before any read. For shared-wiki writes (knowledge_ingest, knowledge_promote), additionally run git -C ~/projects/projects-wiki pull --ff-only — sha-based optimistic lock will reject your commit otherwise."_
|
||
- Trigger reason from user: "projects-meta — это шина между машинами. Юзер на ноуте может не знать, что на десктопе уже был коммит в shared wiki 5 минут назад. Без этого шага write-флоу ломается случайным образом, и баг трудно воспроизвести."
|